Picture this. You've just met someone at an event, and two minutes in, they mention they drive a Ferrari.
Now, on the surface, nothing much has happened. A man told you what car he drives. But watch what happens inside your head. If cars matter to you, a voice pipes up immediately. "I don't have a Ferrari. I'm not as successful as this guy. I wish I were." He can't hear a word of it. You'd never say it out loud. Yet that silent commentary is now coloring everything, how you stand, what you say next, and whether you listen to him at all.
Meanwhile, in his head, a parallel commentary is running about you. And another one about himself. And another about what you must be thinking of him.
Here's the idea I want to share with you today. Whenever you have a conversation with somebody, there are actually eight conversations going on at once: one out loud, and the eight inside two heads. Most of us prepare for the one out loud and get blindsided by the others. Whether you're talking to your teenager, your boss, a client, or your partner, the people who communicate best are the ones who can read the hidden eight. Learn to work with them, and you become dramatically more persuasive, more connected, and harder to rattle. Let me walk you through them.
In case you missed it - the Inner Propaganda audiobook is finally out. If you’ve been meaning to read the book and haven’t found the time, this is your chance. Would LOVE a review once you do. Listen now on Audible.
The eight conversations in every conversation
Let’s start with the three that revolve around you.
The conversations about you
The first is the conversation you're having with yourself about yourself. There's a network in the brain called the default mode network, and when your mind isn't occupied with a task, it drifts straight to you. Your status, your standing, whether people like you, whether you're doing well. It's running during every conversation you have, and it shapes what you're able to hear. Think of receiving feedback at work while your inner commentary says, "I'm useless at this. I knew it. Maybe I'll get fired." You're not actually hearing the feedback anymore. Instead, you're drowning in the story about the feedback, and you walk away worse off.
The second is the conversation they're having with themselves about you. While you're managing your inner commentary, they're running one about you. Are you smart, threatening, attractive, boring, trustworthy, actually listening? You can't hear it, but it's why you smile. It's why you're polite. Every bit of social effort you make is an attempt to influence a conversation happening inside someone else's skull.
This brings us to the third conversation, which is what you want them to say to themselves about you. In my case, the second conversation they might currently be having with themselves might conclude "Owen's a bit of a weirdo." The conversation I'd like them to be having might be "Owen's a smart guy, a decent guy, a funny guy." The gap between those two is what you are trying to close. What do they already know about you? What does your role make them expect? If you're reaching out to sell something, they've likely pre-loaded "this person just wants my money" before you open your mouth. Once you can identify the difference between these two conversations, you can ask the only question that matters: what could I do, especially early, to close that gap?

The conversations about them
The next three conversations are running in the other direction.
The fourth is the conversation they're having with themselves about themselves. This is their identity, how they see who they are. It's sacred ground. If I dismiss you, disrespect you, or label you as something you don't believe yourself to be, you will stop listening to everything I say, because I've failed to recognize who you are. Villains don't walk around thinking they're villains. Whoever you're trying to reach, however wrong you think they are, they have a self-story in which they make sense. Connect with how they see themselves, and they open up. Trample it, and the conversation is over, even if the talking continues.
The fifth is the conversation you're having with yourself about them. Your private running verdict on who this person is. Here's why it matters more than you think: they're scanning for it constantly. If they sense you've already written them off, if they detect the smirk behind your polite questions, your credibility evaporates. People read our verdicts through a hundred tiny leaks. The conversation you have with yourself about them shapes the one you have out loud, whether you intend it to or not.
The sixth is the conversation they want you to have about them. Just as you have a desired identity you're hoping they'll perceive, they have one too. There's a version of themselves they're hoping lands with you, and a gap between how you currently see them and how they'd love to be seen. Spot that gap and you've found gold, because helping someone be seen the way they want to be seen is one of the most powerful connection moves that exists.
The conversations about the topic
The last two are about whatever you're actually discussing. The seventh is the story they tell themselves about the topic. The eighth is the story you tell yourself about it. Sometimes those stories align, and everything flows. Often they don't, and here's the mistake almost everyone makes: we argue about the topic without ever surfacing the two stories about the topic. Where are they currently on this? How did they get there? Where exactly am I, and can I articulate it cleanly? Only when both stories are on the table can you compromise, collaborate, or even just communicate your way somewhere better together.
Eight conversations and each one is a lever.
Fact, interpretation, opinion, truth
One more tool before we finish, because all eight conversations are built from stories, and stories get slippery. When conversations go wrong, it's usually because four very different things have been mashed together.
A fact is what you can both observe and verify. The data points.
An interpretation is the story about what the fact means or why it's happening.
An opinion is the story about what should happen as a result.
Then there's truth, the most abused word of the four. Watch how people use it. Truth gets slapped onto interpretations and opinions like a certification sticker, a way of cranking up certainty without adding a shred of evidence. You've seen the online version: someone states a wildly debatable opinion and then adds the word "Fact." Saying it does not make it so.
Just because an interpretation feels true doesn't make it true. Just because an opinion feels true doesn't make it true. In your next difficult conversation, sort what's being said, by both of you, into those four buckets. It's remarkable how much negative energy drains out of a disagreement when you realize you agree on every fact and differ only on the interpretation.
Watch the full podcast episode here.
The conversation that happens out loud is the smallest part of any conversation. The other eight decide whether you connect or clash, persuade or provoke, hear or merely wait to speak. So before your next important conversation, take five minutes and consider the eight. What am I telling myself about me? What are they likely telling themselves about me, and what do I want them to tell themselves? How do they see themselves, how do I see them, how do they want to be seen? And what's each of our stories about the topic?
Do that, and you'll walk in prepared for the conversation that's actually happening, not just the one being spoken.
Belief Leader of the Week
Nancy Duarte
Nancy Duarte is the CEO of Duarte, Inc., the Silicon Valley communication firm she has run since 1988, and the person the biggest brands in the world call when a message has to land. Her team built the slides behind Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth, and her TEDx talk, “The Secret Structure of Great Talks”, has been watched by millions. She has spent more than three decades studying why some presentations move people and most put them to sleep.
Her core insight is that every great talk has a shape. When she mapped Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream” against Steve Jobs launching the iPhone, she found the same hidden pattern underneath both. The speaker moves back and forth between what is and what could be, over and over, until the gap becomes unbearable and the audience wants to close it themselves. Persuasion, in her world, is the art of making people feel the distance between today and a better tomorrow. The presenter is never the hero. The audience is. Your job is to be their mentor.
I got to meet Nancy back in 2019, and she’s as fascinating in person as she is in her writing. Her books Resonate and Slide:ology are the two that changed how I think about presenting, and DataStory does the same for anyone who has to make numbers mean something. If you ever stand in front of a room and need them to believe you, Resonate is where to start. Essential.
Learn more about Nancy here.
