This episode discusses storytelling and logical fallacies used by Donald Trump and Kamala Harris during their respective convention speeches. This is part two of a series on rhetorical techniques used by both candidates.
Storytelling Techniques
- Personal Anecdotes
- Harris shares a story about her mother’s journey from India and another about her best friend, Wanda, who inspired her to become a prosecutor.
- Trump describes an assassination attempt at his rally and a conversation with a waitress concerned about taxes on her tips.
- Emotional Resonance
- Trump evokes concern and loyalty by detailing the assassination attempt and the crowd’s reaction.
- Harris connects with audiences through stories of her mother’s resilience and her friend Wanda’s trauma.
- Narrative Structure
- Harris structures her speech with a personal history, professional achievements, and future vision.
- Trump focuses on suspense and conflict, often framing his narrative as a battle of “us vs. them.”
- Relatable Characters
- Trump uses ordinary Americans, like a Nevada waitress, as central figures in his movement.
- Harris highlights her childhood community and everyday Americans to emphasize unity and shared values.
- Vision of the Future
- Harris emphasizes a strong middle class, opportunity for all, and reproductive rights.
- Trump promises national greatness, law and order, and a future free from threats.
Logical Fallacies
- Straw Man Fallacy
- Harris: Simplifies Trump’s actions on January 6th as solely for personal benefit.
- Trump: Frames Democrats’ actions as purely vindictive and weaponizing the justice system.
- False Dilemma
- Trump: Suggests that only under his leadership will America succeed.
- Harris: Implies a choice between Trump’s chaos or her stability.
- Slippery Slope
- Harris: Claims Trump’s re-election will lead to authoritarian measures and further restrictions.
- Trump: Warns that Democratic leadership will destroy the country and bring in criminals.
- Ad Hominem
- Trump: Uses nicknames like “Crazy Nancy” to discredit opponents.
- Harris: Labels Trump as “unserious” rather than addressing policies directly.
- Appeal to Fear
- Harris: Warns of Trump’s unrestrained power if re-elected.
- Trump: States the world is on the brink of World War III due to Democrats.
- Hasty Generalization
- Trump: Claims all Democrats are corrupt and the media is fake.
- Harris: Generalizes Trump’s Supreme Court picks as solely anti-reproductive freedom.
- Guilt by Association
- Harris: Associates Trump with extreme anti-abortion views and initiatives.
- Trump: Appeals to tradition by emphasizing a return to past American greatness.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
